Moving towards safer alternatives

092-EN, General section

Alternative to formaldehyde in fluid preservation of biological specimens.

Abstract

22 alternatives were assessed as alternatives to formaldehyde in preserving biological specimens. DMDM-hydantoin was regarded as a suitable alternative. DMDM-hydantoin is also used in pharmaceutical and cosmetic products.

Substituted substance(s)

  1. Formaldehyde

    CAS No. 50-00-0 EC No. 200-001-8 Index No. 605-001-00-5
  2. Ethanol

    CAS No. 64-17-5 EC No. 200-578-6 Index No. 603-002-00-5

Alternative substance(s)

  1. DMDM hydantoin

    CAS No. 6440-58-0 EC No. 229-222-8 Index No. 

Other type of alternative

Reliability of information

Internet information: data are from an internet document and only a basic and partial evaluation could be performed


Hazard assessment

There is limited evidence of carcinogenic effect of formaldehyde and formaldehyde can cause sensitization by skin contact. Formaldehyde is in the database of hazardous substances according to SUBSPORT criteria. Ethanol is flammable. The proposed alternative DMDM-hydantoin is not classified and is not in the database of hazardous substances according to SUBSPORT criteria. It is a formaldehyde releasing substance  allowed in pharmaceutical and cosmetic products.

» Check the Substance Database according to SUBSPORT Screening Criteria (SDSC)

Top of page

Substitution description

Despite that new antiseptic mixtures are introduced in the pharmaceutical and cosmetic industry  every year, fluid preservation of biological specimens are still  based on formaldehyde and ethanol. Ethanol is highly flammable and formaldehyde is recognized as a highly toxic substance. The aim of the study was to determine the suitability of biocides used in the pharmaceutical and cosmetic industry to preserve biological specimens. The biocide was assessed according to six parameters: antiseptic range, water/fat solubility coefficient, pH range,  stability/reactivity, toxicity and flammability. A biocide  out of range of the preset parameters was not considered to be a suitable alternative. First the substances were assessed according to the technical parameters. The substances that passed these were assessed according to the safety parameters. 22 substances were reviewed according to this process: ethanol, isopropanol, formaldehyde, glutaraldehyde, soium benzoate, methylparaben, ethylparaben, propylparaben, butylparaben, chlorhexidine, triclosan, trichlorcarban, hexachlorophene, DMDM-hydantoin, chloroxyenol, silver nitrate, bronopol, phenol, phenoxetol, sodium propionate, benzalkonium chloride, potassium sorbate.

Only DMDM-hydantoin was considered to be a suitable alternative, although DMDM-hydantoin is a formaldehyde-releasing agent. A 55% solution contains 2% released free  formaldehyde and 17-18.5 % bound formaldehyde. Only the free formaldehyde is volatile. In products such as shampoos and skin lotions it is regarded as safe in concentration of 1%.

Ethanol passed all technical parameters but was discarded because of the flammability.

The study concludes, that most biocides used in food, cosmetic and pharmaceutical products are not considered to be suitable for preservation of biological specimens.  DMDM-hydantoin passes all 6 parameters. DMDM-hydantoin has never been used for this purpose and therefore its long term effect on the integrity of the specimens is not known.

Top of page

Case/substitution evaluation

Most of the 22 evaluated alternatives were not technical suitable. Formaldehyde is classified both concerning carcinogenic and sensitizing effect and therefore DMDM-hydantoin is a better alternative. Ethanol also performed well and could be taken into account where flammability is not a problem.

Top of page

Other solutions

Further information

Further languages available


Who provided the information

Type of information supplier
Research

Contact 

Publication source

http://research.nhm.org/library/_media/curation:fluid.jpg?id=curation%3Acuration&cache=cache

Type of publication and availability 

Only abstract freely available

Original document: click here


Comments from SUBSPORT users

Top of page

Publication or last update: 23-05-2012

Logo Grontmij Logo Istas Logo Chemsec Logo Kooperationsstelle Hamburg